Wednesday, June 9, 2010
Do we Maldivians want economic development?
It's disheartening that our focus has shifted more on politics, rather than reforming our economy, and improving productivity in the country. There are many important issues and obstacles for economic growth in our country, and we need to talk about it, address them as soon as we can. Maybe most of the politicians do not understand fully the real consequences, and dangers of economic hardships. When the public comes out, and demonstrates on the road due to economic harships, even the military or police may not be able to stop them. My point is, it's time we all debated about improving our economy, increasing incomes, and achieving economic development. The Parliament must be now debating bills and passing legislation in order to bring about economic reforms and increasing government revenue, reducing government expenditure, and developing the private sector. The government needs to formulate a reform bill and present to the parliament, ways to reduce government expenditure, especially, a detailed plan to reduce government employees and wage bill. Such a plan should have details of compensation packages for those who get unemployed in the short run. It also needs to include plans to developing the private sector, and job creation. The point is, any austerity plan put forward by the government needs to be transparent, and so the parliament and the public endorse it.
The Parliamentarians need to believe that our fiscal deficit was above 20 percent of GDP last year, and the state wage bill is extremely high and unsustainable.
Talking about developing the private sector, there are many talented businessmen as parliamentarians. I'm sure the country would be able to get a better contribution from them, if they were concentrating full time on their private businesses.
The media needs to focus more and divert the public's attention more on the economic issues, instead of wasting resources and time on useless and unproductive battles between DRP and MDP.
Some times I just wonder, do we really want economic development?
Thursday, June 3, 2010
What a crisis world...
The recent events in the world financial markets are worth reflecting on, as we have been seeing times of extreme riskiness. On May 6th, the S&P500 fell from 1165 to 1065 within one day. The following day it was again back at 1135. Since then, the commodity markets, equity markets, and the currency markets are in high volatility, and investors have become very risk averse.
For the last two years (almost), we have been hearing about economic crisis, financial crisis, banking crisis, current-account crisis; it has become a crisis world. Looking at past crises, we saw the ‘Black Monday’ in 1987 when the Dow Jones plummeted almost 508 points and the S&P 500 declined by 20.4 percent within one day. In 1997, there was the East Asian financial crisis, when currencies of Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia depreciated significantly within weeks. In 1999 we had the Argentine economic crisis. In 2007, we started hearing about the signs of a major financial crisis, the one we are still experiencing today.
When USA was almost on the verge of economic recovery, the debt problem of Greece led to a sudden panic in the markets, and Euro has fallen to 1.21 against the US Dollar.
Whenever there is an economic or a financial crisis, many people lose their jobs and income, banks fail, and companies go bankrupt, and so crises are definitely bad for societies. I wonder why we get so much of these crises, in the first place.
Well, we all know how the financial crisis started in USA; with the banks lending excessively to the Americans at low interest rates for home ownership. Most of these mortgage loans were made to the ‘sub-prime’ market, a group of people who had the lowest possibility and capability of repaying the loan. These banks and financial institutions then sold these debt to other institutions, and in this way, new financial products were innovated. Bright minds working in fund management firms came up with ideas like the ‘Credit Default Swaps’ (CDS), which are still another form of financial product, that acts as an insurance to those banks that hold mortgage debt. Trading in equity markets have become too much sophisticated, and mostly has become just numbers in computer systems.
In order to address some of the problems of this sophisticated system, on 24th May, Germany has banned naked short-selling of certain sovereign debt instruments and shares of selected German banks. Although some investors are unhappy about this, I guess, the current crisis originated from actions of many investors trying to make gains in the very short run through short-selling of shares and other financial products.
The whole objective of a financial system is intermediation of finance from savers to investments. We buy shares in order to have ownership of a certain company, and when the firm makes a profit, we get a dividend from it. The company gets the benefit of obtaining finance for its needed investments. Whenever we deviate from this basic fundamental objective, and when financial system is dominated by just hypothetical numbers in electronic devices, we will always be prone to crises.
Talking about sovereign debt problems, the one Greece is facing right now, is again a major reason for an economic crisis. Most of the analysts may be talking about the US economic recovery, what they dont talk about is the US debt problem. As at end 2009, the US debt stood at 83 percent of GDP. Hence, in order to prevent yet another crisis, it has to address its debt problem soon in order to avoid America turning into Greece.
Saturday, May 22, 2010
The Korean story
The per capita GDP was about $100 in the early 1960s, and back then it was among the least developed countries in the world. However, today it’s over $20,000. Korea has become the 4th largest economy in Asia, and is also the world’s 8th largest exporter. It has a very high human development index, and education index. The gross capital formation in 2008 was about 30 percent (world average 22 percent) of GDP, and exports are 53 percent (world average is 29 percent) of GDP. (World Bank)
I can still remember one article written by the famous economist, Paul Krugman, saying that Asian economies’ success is mainly due to the accumulation of inputs, with less technological growth. (Paul Krugman, 1995). While it can be true for Singapore, it seems that its not exactly the case for Korea. Unlike Singapore and most other Asian countries, Korea has internationally successful brands like Samsung, LG, and Hyundai-Kia. And these firms spend huge amounts annually on R&D, thus achieving further innovation.
So, how did South Korea achieve all this? Definitely it has to do with innovation and technological growth. The country is now ranked as the most innovative country in the world in the Global Innovation Index. South Korea has been able to achieve high export-led growth through their innovation. I spent an year in America, and visited many states in the country, visited many universities and institutions. I was amazed by the level of efficiency and technology usage. Believe me, I could feel the same thing in Korea. In some aspects, it beats even America; that we can see even from the numbers. The gross capital formation in America is about 18 percent of GDP, compared to 30 percent in Korea. I'm not by any means saying that Korea is superior to America in terms of technology, but rather trying to express my amazement.
What I’ve noticed through the few days in Korea is that, unlike Singapore, there aren't many expatriate workers around. Unlike USA or UK, I don’t see many immigrants in Seoul. Ok, Korea already has a population of over 50 million, so we can’t compare it to Singapore. However, in terms of attracting international talent, America and Britain have done a great job. The growth in national total factor productivity (TFP) in those countries surely has been influenced by the influx of talented workers from all over the world. But, it’s not the case in Korea. It is one of most demographically homogenous society, with about 99 percent Korean ethnicity. I could notice this by walking around. They also have a well-developed language, and this I could see from their book stores as most of the books were in their own language. I couldn’t find too many books in English from a huge book store in Seoul.
So, back to the success story; What are the lessons that we can learn from Korea? One: Great economic progress can be achieved through effective and efficient utilization of foreign aid by investing on productive industries that can earn foreign exchange to the country. Even if we incur huge external debt, if those funds are wisely invested on productive income generating activities, the country will be getting the benefits of it.
Lesson number two: for economic progress, we need an efficient governing system, with less political conflicts. One could do a good control experiment, if we consider the neighboring North Korea, almost identical in terms of resources, ethnicity and climate; with the main difference in their governing system. One could see the huge difference between the two countries in terms of economic power.
Lesson three: emphasis should be on developing the private sector, and the private sector should be the engine of economic growth.
These are all important lessons for all other developing countries. As for Maldives, surely we don’t have 50 million people, and enough land. However, most of our economic problems facing today, are due to our low focus on developing the private sector, and the over-reliance on the government. When we come to think of it, many of highly educated youth are employed in the government and engaged in economically unproductive work. In order to achieve economic progress, we need productive investments in the private sector. We citizens need to focus more on economic activities, rather than wasting our time on unproductive political fights. If we need to pressure the government, it has to be on developing the private sectors, so that we can earn an income, rather than asking the government to give us subsidies to pay our bills. Most of all, we need a strategic macroeconomic vision, and a master plan for the future.
Saturday, May 8, 2010
Greece would have been better off without euro?
The crisis in Greece has done much damage to the mighty euro, which has reached 1.25 to a US dollar on May 06th 2010, which had a rate of about 1.40 at the end of January. With the adoption of euro, the Greek economy attracted a lot of foreign financing inflows, and international investors became overly optimistic about the Greek economy. With the global economic down-turn, these inflows almost stopped, and Greece had to face the reality. A reality in which its government spending has escalated, prices and wages have increased dramatically. The government deficit as a percentage of GDP has reached to unsustainable levels.
So, why has Greece become so helpless with its high debt? The answer is simple; it is tied with the euro, and it does not have the luxury of an independent monetary policy. Had Greece had its own currency, its central bank would have had the chance to have an independent monetary policy. It would have been able to have a monetary expansion, or devalue its currency in order to obtain some degree of international competitiveness.
But now, Greece is forced to be dependent on the strong European nations to provide the needed assistance, and if they fail to do so, there is less hope that Greek economy can come out of this crisis. Hence, even now it might be best for Greece and also for the rest of euro-countries, if Greece abandon the euro, and have its own currency once again.
What have we learnt from all this? One;, in order to have a common currency we need synchronized fiscal policies and fiscal discipline. If it cannot be achieved, it will be almost impossible to have a common monetary policy. Afterall, at the end of the day, Its Mostly Fiscal (IMF). Two;, it is extremely difficult to have a common monetary policy and monetary union (with common currency), without political union or common sovereignty. As people in countries like Germany will be less willing to finance the fiscal irresponsibilities of other countries, like Greece. If the whole euro area was one single sovereign state like that of United States, it would have been politically plausible to provide federal funds or assistance to those states with difficulties.
But now, when the crisis has hit Greece, its government is not able to act with an independent monetary policy. And, its too much to expect that all the other european countries will go on providing assistance to Greece. I wonder, if it'll be better for Greece to let go of euro, and have its own currency.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Maldives economy is far from recovery
Maldives economy entered into a state of economic ‘crisis’ in 2008, coinciding with the global economic downturn. However, the ‘sickness’ in our economy is mostly of our own making, as our government spending reached Rf8 billion in 2007, followed by Rf10 billion in 2008. The government deficit stood at 17 percent of GDP in 2008, which is an unsustainable level of deficit even in international standards. In 2009, the deficit reached an alarming 26 percent of GDP. Until August 2009, part of the deficit was financed through printing Rufiyaa, which then led to increased circulation of Rufiyaa in the economy, and hiking inflation in 2008 to 12.3 percent. Although inflation has dropped to about 4 percent in 2010, we are still not recovered from the most dangerous sickness that we’ve inflicted. The unsustainable level of government spending, the resulting fiscal deficit, which was about one third of the GDP in 2009. We’ve still not started to live within our means. The estimated deficit for this year is about Rf4 billion, and it is estimated to be about 19 percent of GDP, which is much higher than that of Greece (12 percent).
It was relieving news that Maldives entered into a stand-by arrangement with the IMF last year, and that there were some macro economic performance criteria set and agreed by the government. However, we still have a long way to go. We still have yet to introduce measures to increase government revenue, through an effective tax system. We still have yet to revive our private sector investments in order to achieve higher economic growth. We still have got the task of reducing government expenditure and deficit. We still got to reduce our foreign currency spending. We still got to start living within our means.
According to the available statistics, the growth in lending to private sector by the commercial banks is on a declining trend, in fact, there was an annual decline by 5 percent as at end of February 2010. Meanwhile, lending to the government by the banks has increased by 13 percent during the same period. This means, unless there is a way to reduce government expenditure, banks may not be lending to the private sector, and we might not see an active private sector in the near future.
Bottom line is, in order to see economic recovery, we need to put our house in order, and start living within our means.
Data Source: Maldives Monetary Authority, Monthly Statistics, April 2010, www.mma.gov.mv
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Adverse Selection at its best in Maldives…
I remember one of my professors explaining to me the difference between regulating a restaurant and a bank. He says that even if five restaurants closed down within a week, it doesn’t affect much to the macro economy; however, if even one bank was to fail each week, then it sure will impact the macro economy of the country. It is because of this reason, we need an authority (an effective one), to regulate, supervise, and monitor the activities of commercial banks and other financial institutions.
The under-developed financial sector of Maldives has six commercial banks, a leasing company, and a housing development finance corporation. The commercial banks mainly rely on their lending to the tourism sector for most of their profits. According to the published statistics from the regulating authority, MMA, 59 percent of the total lending of the banks is to the tourism sector, as at end of 2009. There is an outstanding amount of over $700 million (Rf 9 billion) lent to the tourism sector at the end of 2009. According to the website of MMA, the lending rates of the commercial banks in Rufiya ranges between 8 through 13 percent, and for US Dollars it is 5.5 through 13 percent.
The banks normally think that their profits will increase if they lend at higher interest rates; as high as 13 percent. However, what they don’t realize is that at such higher rates, there will come many borrowers who do not have the intention of repaying back. There will come many businessmen, with risky projects, having very high uncertainty of recovering the investments. The banks hence face the problem of adverse selection. This is exactly what has happened to some banks in Maldives. In order to record higher bank profits, the bank managers decided to lend huge amounts to very risky borrowers, when these risky borrowers did not have the intention of repaying back, in the first place. So, we can argue that with the increase in interest rate (lending rate), the probability of repaying back falls, and the profitability of banks fall.
Another very good example of adverse selection was seen in the tourism sector few years back, when the Ministry of Tourism opened several invitations to bid for new islands for resort development. Many parties proposed incredibly high rents, and they were awarded the island. What the government did not realize was; the probability of the investor making regular rent payments; and even the probability of the investor ever being able to develop the island and open the resort, decreases with every percentage increase in the rent proposed. In other words, by selecting the party with highest rent, the government is effectively selecting the party with the lowest probability of making the rent payments, and the party with the lowest probability of ever being able to develop the island. I think the evidence we see now supports this claim. There are still more than fifty islands unable to start their operations. And one of the main reasons they are unable to attract finance is due to the incredibly high rents that they need to pay the government.
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Greek and Maldives' economy
According to available statistics, Greece needs more than $13 billion to cover part of its debt coming due in May 2010. The total debt comes to about $400 billion, out of which $72 billion is due this year.
Because of the crisis in Greece, fellow eurozone members are worried, as a troubled Greek economy will surely pose problems to the euro economy, and the euro currency. Hence, it is in the best interest to all the member countries to salvage Greece.
We all have heard on the news that Greek authorities implemented a series of austerity measures; including tax increases, and wage cuts for government employees. This has led to demonstrations and unrest across the country. Civil servants conducted large demonstrations and strike in Athens.
All these sound familiar, right? The Maldives budget deficit was 26.1 percent of GDP in 2009, and is expected to fall to only 18.7 percent of GDP even this year. Maldives could be the country with the highest government deficit as a percentage of GDP in the whole world. We also could be the only country with the highest government wage bill as a percentage of GDP. We are spending about Rf 4 billion within a year to pay for salaries of all public employees; including civil servants, politicians, parliamentarians, and those in the independent institutions. Meaning we spend about Rf 400 million every month, only on salaries!
Our present government announced several austerity measures as well, including reduction of salaries, and reducing the number of civil servants. What followed is similar to what is happening in Greece. I say, there might come a time, when the international partners will abandon us, asking us to manage our expenses within our means. We are not Greece; there is no interest for the Europeans to save us. Our economy is insignificant to the region, and the world. Unless we manage our expenses and our economy, we will not be able to come out of this economic recession.
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
We need to reform IMF...?

The governing structure of IMF was formed in 1944 under the Bretton Woods Conference. However, a lot have changed since then in terms of size of economies, population of countries, share of world trade, reserves, and countries’ abilities to contribute to financial resources. Hence, it is evident that there is a need for reform of this important multilateral financial institution in order to achieve more effective financial global governance.
Here, I will highlight the main issues on the IMF Reform agenda put forward few years back.
The main reforms:
1. Making surveillance more effective
According to Article I of the Articles of Agreement of the IMF, one of the main purposes of the Fund is to ‘promote international monetary cooperation through a permanent institution which provides the machinery for consultation and collaboration on international monetary problems’. In order to achieve this important mission, Article IV of the same Agreement stipulates that all member countries are required to collaborate with the Fund to assure orderly exchange arrangements and to promote a stable system of exchange rates.
However, recently the Fund has very much being criticized on its inability to influence the policies of powerful countries like USA, especially even when economies of such countries have a significant impact on the economies of developing countries.
One such criticism is that, “when the Fund consults with a poor and weak country, the country gets in line. When the Fund consults with a big and strong country, the Fund gets in line”.
As Ariel observed, ‘the world moves away from rules-based multilateral system to a power-based system’, whereby, larger powerful countries ‘go their own way based on their short term interests’ (Ariel 2005).
This was very much evident during the time when the United States Treasury responded to an IMF report, which highlighted the importance of the US current account deficit and the growing indebtedness, by stating that Treasury did not consider that a correction was necessary in its domestic policy (Ariel 2005).
In order to overcome this problem, the Managing Director’s Report 2005 recommended, ‘more incisive analysis of specific weaknesses and distortions that risk crises and contagion or hinder adjustment to gloabalization’. The Managing Director’s Report further describes various specific action plans that can be implemented to achieve the above mentioned recommendation; global surveillance, multilateral dialogue, financial market surveillance, having standards & codes, regional surveillance, country surveillance, and communications strategy.
2. Adapting to new challenges and needs in different member countries
The Managing Director’s Report outlines specific actions to be taken in terms of the Fund’s role towards the advanced, emerging and low-income countries.
With regard to advanced economies it is recommended that global implications are integrated into country specific policies.
Emerging market economies are characterized in the Report as the ones that need crisis prevention and resolution due to their high ‘risk of boom-bust cycles emanating from the volatility of capital flows’ (IMF 2005). Improving financial insurance in these countries is also on the agenda, with particular emphasis on helping member countries to ‘develop local financial markets and instruments’.
Finally, the role in low-income countries is recommended to be more focused, with more flexibility, more emphasis on the Millennium Development Goals, and having fewer procedures.
3. Helping build institutions and capacity
The Fund recognizes the need to further strengthen its ability to provide technical assistance to countries in the area of capacity building and improving institutions. The specific action recommended by the Fund is ‘to give area departments the central role in setting technical assistance priorities in the context of Article IV surveillance and Fund supported programs’. The Fund also acknowledges the need to enhance fiscal transparency and governance as they play an important role in the development of economic institutions.
Although the need for better institutions and capacity building is acknowledged and important, it is questionable how much overlapping and duplication is present in terms of providing technical assistance to member countries, between IMF and the World Bank. Hence, further reform in this area needs to consider this aspect and coordinate better with the Bank on matters relating to capacity building.
4. Prioritization and reorganization of work within a prudent medium-term budget
The Fund highlights the need ‘set priorities for the next few years based on a country-by-country analysis’.
The Fund also needs the reorganization which is necessary to implement the various components of the budget and hence recommends better organization of expert staff, departmental structure, management, executive board, and international monetary and financial committee.
5. Address the issue of fair quotas and voice
In order to achieve the mission of IMF more effectively, it needs to reallocate quotas and voting rights in order to reflect the changes that has taken place in the world economy during the past sixty years. The reallocation should be in such a way to reflect the interests and power of those countries whose share in the world economy has increased, and in general, in a way that the legitimacy of the Fund could be greater.
Concluding Remarks
The G-7 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors met in Tokyo on February 09th 2008 and discussed about IMF reforms, reaffirming their support on the IMF surveillance decision on exchange rate, fiscal and monetary policies. In their statement they expressed their support for the “proposal of the Managing Director to refocus the Fund’s operations on core priorities”. This is a positive message that reflects the commitment from the richest nations of the world, and is expected to have a significant impact on the reform agenda of the Fund.
The reforms outlined above are those highlighted in the Managing Director’s Report, 2005 and in addition to these, there are few other areas that need attention.
Some of them include, making the work of the Fund in the member countries more ‘demand-oriented’ taking into account the local circumstances and needs of the countries, rather than being ‘supply-oriented’ by the replicating what is being done in many other countries. In some countries, some of the new projects or policy recommendations are suggested and being ‘forced’ to be developed into loans, even though such loans are not diverted to the most efficient use or sector. In the meantime, there are many other areas that need special attention and assistance, but unable to attract the attention of the Fund or the Bank, as the officials of these institutions do not feel that they are important.
Finally, it has to be emphasized that rich and powerful countries need to be brought on-board in understanding the importance of global financial governance, and the relative effects of global integration, and thus adapting policies that can have positive impacts on the world economy.
In order to achieve ability to force corrective action on its members, the Fund needs reorganization and reallocation of its quotas and voting rights. Reallocation of quotas is also important in order to improve the legitimacy of the institution and hence, achieve the core objectives of the Fund.
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Foreign Aid - Is it free?
Foreign aid has attracted a bit more attention lately, but it has, since its inception in 1950, been a controversial issue. Recently a book by William Easterly (Title: The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s efforts to aid the rest have done so much ill and so little good. Publisher: Penguin Press, 2006) has set off a new round of discussions and questions and polemics. So I thought that I would join in.
I will concentrate on Official Development Assistance (ODA), essentially aid in the form of funds given by the rich countries to the low and middle GDP countries of the world. ODA is the largest of the various aid categories. I may try to discuss other categories, especially technical aid, in a later post.
Official Development Assistance has been of significant size. In the year 2006, for example, it amounted to $120 billion in current prices. (This is the world total.) This seems to me to be a sizeable figure, but it is a small proportion of the West’s Gross National Income, and it was spread over many countries, not necessarily on the basis of need or the ability of a country to use it productively.
This foreign aid of course is meant to provide a country with resources in addition to those of its own. Aid then is a supplement to domestic saving. Government can then do things it could not have done without the aid. This is obvious of course. Suppose a government is using its own resources effectively, and then gets some aid. It can then do more–can build more elementary schools, can improve or maintain more roads, can guarantee farmers a good price for their crops, and so on–than it could in the absence of aid. Aid obviously can be of great help in the development of a country. Why are there doubts?
There are several reasons that have been mentioned by opponents of aid. It breeds corruption, it is wasted on pet projects pushed by some government officials, it enables the continuation of harmful policies, it makes exchange rate management more complicated, it dampens pressure on domestic resources to seek productivity gains, donor countries often put damaging restrictions on the use of aid funds, and so on and on. These doubts are real and there are many examples that one could cite of their impact. At the same time there are many examples of aid having a very favorable effect on a country’s development effort. Botswana and Korea are examples of aid working in an effective way.
For aid to be effective the overall economic policy of a country must be in order. The country must understand how its economy functions. As noted above the aid receiving country must be using its own resources effectively and to appreciate how it can use additional resources in an equally effective way. This is not an easy thing to do. And it is not surprising that aid is often misused, not because of corruption or selfish government officials, but because the understanding of the aid receiver’s economy is so limited. Thus foreign aid is beneficial where those who manage the economy understand how their economy in fact works. Where the donor imposes conditions for its aid that the recipient believes to be inappropiate, aid must be rejected. Do not think because it is aid it is free, and doesn’t matter. The costs may be high. There is no such thing as free aid, as there is no such thing as a free lunch.
Monday, January 25, 2010
What the government and the civil servants need to understand on the issue of salaries
The years following 2004 tsunami, the macroeconomic management can be best described as ‘stupid’, ‘politically-motivated’, and mostly unsustainable. Government’s current expenditure hiked to unsustainable levels, mostly through increasing salaries, and huge promotions. This was followed by formation of many independent commissions and institutions, again with huge salaries. Meanwhile, salaries of the Parliamentarians, and ministers also increased drastically. All these led to extremely high government budget deficit, that was financed through printing Rufiyaa. This led to increasing inflation, as equivalent goods and services were not produced, and the productivity in the economy did not improve.
International financial institutions like IMF, World Bank, and Asian Development Bank, all advocate reducing government deficit and stop printing Rufiyaa to finance the deficit. (http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pr/2010/pr1013.htm)The government expenditure has to be financed through revenue collected from taxation. Not by any means through printing Rufiyaa. Whenever we print Rufiyaa, we’re adding up to our problems, as it’d lead to higher inflation, and difficulties in obtaining US dollars. These financial institutions who provide assistance to us, have been advising us to reduce the redundant civil servants, stop subsidizing STELCO (by increasing the electricity prices), and reduce the government wage bill.
The rationale is: we cannot continue paying higher salaries to many staff who do not add any value. In other words, we pay salaries to government employees in order to provide some services to the public. We need to reduce the number of government employees, so that redundant, or unnecessary staff are removed, so that they can get employed elsewhere. Regarding the salaries, it is common sense that anybody, even if it’s the government, cannot continue to pay higher salaries, if it cannot raise enough revenue to pay for that. So, reducing salaries would be the best option in order to reduce government expenditure and deficit. If not, deficit will have to be financed through borrowing or printing Rufiyaa, both options being bad for the economy.
Reducing salaries of civil servants, reducing the number of civil servants, and increasing electricity prices, are all political suicides for a president or a government. However, the current government was forced to take these steps, as it was recommended by the IMF, and many other donors. Further, the assistance package provided by IMF requires government to reduce the deficit levels to certain levels or targets, and for such conformity, these steps have become necessary. So obviously, the government’s policy and decisions are for the future benefit of our country.
But, why are the civil servants, and the civil service commission still protesting, and demanding higher pay? Answer is simple; although the government’s economic plan is prudent, and is necessary for the country, the sincerity of the government is being questioned by the civil servants and the public. Why do I say that?
If there were same principles applied to all employed staff of the state, including, civil servants, political appointees, staff of independent commissions, and parliamentarians, then, it is more likely that the civil servants would have accepted a lower pay even for the whole year. However, what we see is that political posts keep on increasing, and the salaries of parliamentarians and some of the independent institutions were not reduced.
The IMF and those institutions advise to reduce the total wage bill. The total wage bill includes the salaries of all political posts, parliamentarians, and civil servants. So, if we are talking about reducing the number of civil servants by laying off redundant workers, then the same principle needs to be applied to political appointees as well. Redundant political appointees need to be laid off. Just like civil service staff are hired and employed based on their performance, need, and productivity; even political appointees should be appointed and employed based on the need, their performance, and the productivity. The salaries of political appointees and the civil servants, and even the parliamentarians are paid by the same budget; the state budget. Hence, in order to show sincerity, and commitment to reducing government expenditure and deficit, government needs to apply same principles, and treat everybody impartially. Government needs to lead by example.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
don't worry...be happy.. :-)
Talking about happiness, it could be the case that different people interpret happiness in different ways. For me, happiness means feeling good, enjoying life, and think to myself, “What a wonderful world”! Happiness has many dimensions; we feel different at different times of the day, when we are with different people, and when we are doing different things. A study done in 2003 by Kahneman et al, in which 1000 working women in Texas were asked how they felt at different times of the day. The results are reproduced here.
According to the results, Americans felt least happy while commuting, and the highest index is for sex. This could obviously vary for different societies, and I don’t know which activity makes Maldivians happier.
The same study determined, how happy they were spending time with different people, and showed that they were happiest while spending time with their friends (3.3), and least happy while with their boss (2.0).
Layard raises an interesting point, that people in the west have become much richer, work much less, have more holidays, travel more, live longer, are healthier, but, still they haven’t got happier. So what shall we do, to make us happier?
Sunday, January 17, 2010
10 things I hate about MONEY
1. Live within your means and monitor how you spend your money
2. Save a portion of your income before spending the balance. Aim to keep six months of income for emergencies
3. Make use of credit cards wisely and settle debts promptly to minimize interest charges
4. Gather information and shop around before buying any financial product
5. Buy a financial product only that you understand. Read the terms and conditions carefully before you buy any financial product.
6. Understand what your insurance policy covers. Pay attention to exclusions and other terms and conditions of your policy contract
7. Be careful about buying any financial product on impulse. Determine your need and buy what is suitable for you
8. Do not give into persistent sales tactics and learn to say ‘No’
9. Plan early for your retirement. The government pension scheme normally covers only the basic retirement needs
10. Invest wisely by spreading the money over different types of investments. A financial product that has a higher return usually comes with higher risks as well
Source: Singapore ‘Money Sense’ program, 2004